11 Smart Ways to Handle the Political Talk at Thanksgiving This Year

For the Mom Who Escapes to the Dishes Mid-Argument
Know someone who could use a line or two? Send her this episode, and if it helps, leave a 5-star rating wherever you listen.
A few years ago, a heated family argument sent my straight to the sink to play dishwasher Tetris (you know, loading the dishes in there just so. With the election behind us and Thanksgiving days away, I share 11 things to say when a family gathering turns political, sorted into three groups: lines for when you're done, lines for a real conversation, and lines that let the air out of the room. You only need one or two.
Who Should Listen
Moms dreading a Thanksgiving table where strong opinions are about to collide
The family peacekeeper who quietly manages everyone's feelings at gatherings
Conflict-avoiders who retreat to the kitchen, the bathroom, or the sink when things heat up
Anyone still feeling a little raw after the election who wants a few simple things to say
Listeners who want to keep the peace without arguing or sitting in silence

Chapters / Timestamps
00:00 – Intro: A heated family argument and a retreat to the sink
01:39 – Welcome and why this episode is back
03:43 – The 11 Lines And Three Groups
04:09 – Group 1: "I'm not doing this today" (2 lines)
05:33 – Group 2: "I'm up for a real conversation" (6 lines)
09:22 – Group 3: The pressure valve (3 lines)
10:59 – What hit me: the mental load, with pie
13:39 – Closing: this too shall pass
What You Get In This Episode
11 things to say when a family gathering turns political, sorted by what you need: a way out, a real conversation, or a lighter mood
A few examples of lines you can use right away, from "Tell me more" to a food redirect about who's bringing the cranberry sauce
Why the job of keeping the peace at family gatherings so often lands on one person (the mental load again, but with pie)
A reminder that one or two lines in your back pocket is plenty
A reassurance for the hard moments: the holidays are temporary
Host Bio
Caitlin Kindred is the host of Not Quite Grownup, a podcast for moms navigating the gap between who they're "supposed" to be and the messy, real version of adulthood.
Sources & Mentions
"11 Things to Say to Your Relative Whose Politics You Hate", TIME (2024), by Angela Haupt, the source for most of the lines in this episode
Nealin Parker, Executive Director of Common Ground USA, an organization dedicated to peace-building, featured in the TIME article
Other experts quoted in the TIME article: Jenna Glover (Headspace), Jill DeTemple (Southern Methodist University), and Bradford Stucki (psychotherapist)
Paul Osincup, comedian and author of The Humor Habit, for the "comic triple"
Jackie on Instagram, @kindminds_smarthearts, for the reminder that the holidays are temporary
"Everybody Wants to Rule the World" by Tears for Fears, the song stuck in Caitlin's head at the sink

Quick Poll 🗣️
Tell us about your political talk at Thanksgiving.
Do you think you'll need these for the holidays this year?
Nope, all good with the fam
Oh yeah, it'll be chaos
Read this Episode's Full Transcript
11 Smart Ways to Handle Political Talk at Thanksgiving This Year
Caitlin K.: [00:00:00] Let me take you back in time a couple of years. It's Christmas, I think. Maybe it's the day after Thanksgiving. It really doesn't matter . What does matter is that somehow my family ends up on the topic of the health insurance debate that was all over the news a while ago. I'll spare you the details here, but that conversation got heated. Like really heated.
I am someone who talks a big game, especially in the shower where I win every single argument, but I hate confrontation. And I remember trying to keep the peace by pointing out where we all agreed. And when it became clear to me that it was gonna get and stay uncomfortable, I bailed.
I remember feeling myself start to sweat because that's what I do. Start to pit out immediately, right? Who [00:01:00] doesn't? Uh, I remember my cheeks starting to feel really hot. I was probably fanning my pits.
I don't remember how I got there, but I remember being at the sink. I think I started doing the dishes maybe. You know, like drowning out the discomfort with water running and loudly playing Tetris with all the dishes so that everything fits. I even remember hearing "Everybody Wants to Rule the World" by Tears for Fears in my head which by the way is 10 out of 10 song, no notes.
Welcome
Caitlin K.: I'm Kaitlin, and welcome to Not Quite Grown Up, the show for moms trying to keep everything together one basic B- word pumpkin spice latte at a time. Please, if you haven't, give me a five-star rating wherever you listen to podcasts. It really helps new listeners find me, and welcome to all of you who are [00:02:00] new.
Let's get back into it.
Why this is so exhausting
Caitlin K.: Anyway, elections leave all of us a little raw, emotionally exposed, vulnerable, whatever, whatever the word is, and Thanksgiving is right around the corner, which means very soon you are potentially sitting across from someone who feels very differently about how it all went. I first covered this back in 2024, and as the political climate of our country has heated up, it's only gotten more useful. So I feel like now is a good time to revisit this topic. Because those events, those family events can be really hard. It's supposed to be a happy time. We're supposed to be thankful that we're seeing everyone and celebrating whatever it is we celebrate during these holidays.
But you're scanning the guest list, mapping out where your mean-ass cousin is gonna sit so that you don't have to deal with her, [00:03:00] and you're rehearsing your own comebacks in the shower, again, where you win every argument. Or if you're me, you're anxious about the confrontation that could happen, and you are concerning yourself with the damage control piece.Maybe it's your job to always do damage control, which is a different kind of exhausting. Lots of us put up a few barriers around this time of year to protect our peace, and same, I've done it.
If you can't skip these gatherings, which by the way, again, plenty of us have done, I've got 11 lines here to help you.
Most of them come from a 2024 Time article by Angela Haupt. It features Nealin Parker, who is the executive director of Common Ground USA, which is an organization dedicated to peace- building and helping people with difficult relationships. Anyway, [00:04:00] I divided the lines into three groups. I'll name the groups, I'll say the lines, you decide which will work best for you.
Group 1: I'm not doing this today
Caitlin K.: So the first group is the I'm not doing this today group.
You've got two lines here. One, I won't be talking about politics today. Just make your intentions clear ahead of time. Keep the focus on the kids, the festivities. Ask for other people to commit to skipping polarizing topics for you and your family's sanity. You could also say, "Okay, that's enough of that," or, "We're not talking about that here today."
If you guys could see my hands and the way that I am gesturing. Let me know if you want me to turn this into a video podcast. I have no makeup on. This could be interesting.
Anyway, second line, maybe we could revisit this when we're both feeling more calm [00:05:00] If I said that, I'd sound like such a grown-up, which is the point of this podcast.
That'd be amazing. If your pulse is spiking, like how mine does or you start to pit out, you are allowed to step away and say, "Let's just take a break from this. Let's revisit this at a later date." And then you never bring it up again.
If someone won't let it go and wants a fight, just remember you don't have to participate. You don't have to attend every argument you're invited to. So sometimes removing yourself is the move.
Group 2: I'm up for a conversation
Caitlin K.: Okay, the second group. This is the I'm up for a real conversation group. And just a note here, if you don't want to learn anything from these people, you don't want to keep the relationship, you can skip this. That's fine. You don't have to do anything with this group. It might not be - one of the ones on your list. That's totally okay.
So line number three in all of this, in the groupings, can you tell me a story [00:06:00] that helps me understand how you came to believe that? The story behind a belief can help remind you of why you love this person, but it can also be very enlightening, um, and kind of help you, uh, uh, find some humanism in wha- in whatever's happening, whatever the conversation is.
I like this one. This one feels just a tiny bit, tiny bit, like, edgy, which is what I like about it. If I heard only what was on your newsfeed, I'm sure I'd think the same thing, but I've had different experiences in my life. Like this Nealin Parker, who's the person I mentioned earlier, considers this particular line to be a, a nice little reminder that even compelling news stories really don't apply to everyone's lives, at least not equally, right?[00:07:00]
This is our friend Jenny's favorite. Tell me more. Say more about that. It's the opposite of say less. Say less is like, "Yes, I'm there. Say less. All right, I got it." But tell me more, you are getting them to stop ranting at you, hopefully not at you, but they're ranting, to actually talking because all of a sudden you've said a sentence that's a signal to them that they're about to be heard. They don't have to scream because you're going to listen when you say, "Tell me more." That's number five.
Number six, what kind of compromise or solution might work for both sides? Well, now they're having to stop ranting about a problem and become solution-focused, and there is a chance there that in the solution there could be some middle ground. There may not be, okay? So maybe that one's not for you. But at least it [00:08:00] has the potential to put you on the same team.
Uh, I also like this one: "Would it be okay if I shared my point of view here?" It's a counseling technique actually. It's called elicit, provide, elicit. Basically you ask what their view is, you share yours, and then you ask for their reaction on yours. It, it happens a lot in, in, uh, like couples therapy.
Number eight, I'd like a chance to learn from each other because I respect you and I see the world differently. In the past you've heard me say I don't use the word but. "I love you but..." the but negates everything. "I love you but I see the world differently. I respect you but I see the world differently." Those, that sounds different from "I love you and I see the world differently. I respect you and I see the world differently." And it [00:09:00] also shows that you're being intentional about what you're saying. And then take them up on it, right? Mean it when you say that. Try a one-on-one conversation, and it's okay to agree to disagree and walk away. Accept, like, non-resolution as an outcome here.
Group 3: Redirections
Caitlin K.: Okay, group three has nine, 10, and 11 in it. These are like redirections essentially, and you can definitely use a little bit of humor here, which is the Chandler Bing, Caitlin Kindred defense mechanism here.
I loved this idea from Paul Osincup. He's the author of a book called The Humor Habit, and he calls it the comic triple. So you list three things, two that are blah, and one that's surprising. I- I- it's as easy as something like, "Uh, you know, I'll, I'll vote for anyone who, uh, [00:10:00] fixes the potholes on my street and brings back the good Halloween candy and then gets my son to wear a jacket when it's cold out." Done.
Another line, "I'm just glad all the commercials and text messages have stopped." Right?
The last one, the food, the food redirect. Th- these are, I'm intending you to use these around the winter holidays, which tend to be very food-focused, right? So there is nothing wrong with interrupting and just saying, "Okay, well, who's responsible for the cranberry sauce and the kickass pecan pie this year?" By the way, I chose those things 'cause I'm the one responsible for those this year.
Okay, so that's it. That's the list. You don't need all 11 lines. Just choose one or two, maybe listen to the groups again. Put them in your notes app or write them on a slip of paper and literally put that in your back pocket.
My epiphany
Caitlin K.: Here's [00:11:00] what hit me while I was putting this episode together for a little revisit here.
Family gatherings are often set up so that one person, cough mom cough, quietly has to carry out the job of keeping the peace and managing everyone's feelings. Nobody assigned that person that job. It's never on a list.
It's not like, you know, "Bake pecan pie, make cranberry sauce, manage everyone's feelings," because it's part of that mental load again, but this time there's pie involved.
But also, the other thing that hit me was that to make things worse about this, somewhere along the way, we got this idea that the only two options are to argue back, which is a choice, or to [00:12:00] sit there and nod, also a choice, or in my case, go do the dishes. But that's not how it has to go.
Looking back, my experience happened after I had done this episode in 2024. I wish I had remembered even one of these lines, because there are ways to diffuse the situation. There are ways to end the conversation, and hopefully no one's feelings are hurt. But also, no one has to win anything. It's not a competition.
Closing
Caitlin K.: So I'm gonna close by asking which line or two are you gonna hold onto?
But just remember that even with a line in your back pocket, you might still end up stuck in some sort of conversation hell hole. Maybe your mean-ass cousin will never drop it. Maybe your table will never be calm.[00:13:00]
There's a Instagram account I follow called kindminds_smarthearts. Her name is Jackie. She reminded me that the holidays are temporary. Yes, family stuff can absolutely suck, like suuuuuuuuck.
And you know what? This too shall pass.
And you know, whatever. If all else fails, I'll be at the sink loudly playing dishwasher Tetris. You can come join me. I'll wash, you dry.
If you know someone who could use a line or two, send her this episode. Tell her to listen to it right before Thanksgiving to help gird her ovaries. She'll thank you for it.
Love you, mean it. Bye.



Comments